Loreal H.I.P Cream Eyeliner

I love this eyeliner! It stays on forever, probably 5 times longer than a stick liner. I haven't tried M.A.C fluid line (which is most likely better) but for me this works. You'll never run out, I've had mine for months, and it you go over your line with a black eyeshadow to set it, it will stay on FOREVER! Definitely a good drugstore liner, the brush sucks though it'll scratch your eye off. Invest in a good, soft angle brush.
                                                              
4 out of 5 stars

*this is only my personal opinion, everyone may view this product differently